A Regency Romance

What explains the enduring appeal of the Regency Romance?

Why has that period in history lent itself more than any other to our fantasies about courtship and social acceptance? The origins of its potency lie older and deeper than the comedies of manners written prolifically by Georgette Heyer, the doyenne of Regency Romance fiction, and the costume rom-coms of the film and movie industries of the last hundred years.

Regency Romance is written to a winning formula nowadays, some of it blissfully unconcerned with syntax or history, but millions of women had fallen in love with Classic Literature’s Mr Darcy for nearly two centuries before the BBC got him wet.  Members of all sexes have obsessed over the period’s dead poets with a sense of connection that felt stronger than many real relationships. Many a girl and boy have thrilled to Byron’s “mad, bad and dangerous” celebrity, or pined to be the one to soothe Keats’ fevered forehead, rather than inadequate Fanny Brawne.

We are all touched by the Regency, even those of us who have never read a romantic novel or would know a pelisse if it arrested us.


John Arthur Douglas Bloomfield, 2nd Baron Bloomfield, already a career diplomat at the age of seventeen, a pillar of the Establishment trying desperately to look like poet, libertarian political writer and social outcast Lord Byron, painted at full Romantic throttle by Thomas Lawrence, 1819. (National Portrait Gallery. Image: Wikipedia).
The Regency created its own romantically sexy myth long before it was appropriated by later generations.

The Regency period looks more modern to us than either the preceding 18th century age or the following Victorian age. The style of clothes and short hairstyles are still around – even the men’s tight-fitting trousers have been revived as jeggings.

Regency architecture, interior and garden design still provide some of the most elegant home improvement options available today.

EdmundBlairLeightonOntheThresholdEdmund Leighton: On the Threshold (1900). Manchester Art Gallery. Image source: Wikipedia
Love the wrought iron and lead roofed porch. And his boots….

A late Victorian nostalgia for Regency style packaged the romance of consumerism, in which props and set dressing are more prominent than feelings. You’d never guess from later illustrations that there had been a war going on, in fact several wars, about ideology, trade, territory and ideas.

Women’s clothes in the neoclassical Regency period, for three decades after the French Revolution, were more comfortable, more symbolic of personal freedom, than later 19th and early 20th century fashions. By the late 1820s, tight lacing was back and got tighter. (Traditional stays had never really gone away for every woman in Regency times, and were superseded by the much-maligned corset which, correctly fitted, is far more comfortable and good for posture than its reputation allows. And some of us are comfortable and happier in high heels, just as some people have sea legs – but that’s for another battle at the Last Post.)

The female body of the following four generations was squeezed in and padded out, satisfying somebody or other’s fetishes, some of them as weird as Comic Con costumes.

At the time Edmund Leighton was turning out his chocolate box historical genre scenes, and C.E. Brock was producing his fairytale illustrations to Jane Austen, fashionable women’s bodies were trapped in S-shaped cages which they only started getting out of shortly before World War I. The Regency looked like a time of rationality and enlightenment in comparison.

Bingley&Jane. Brock

One of the later (1907) watercolour versions of C.E. Brock’s original 1895 illustrations to Pride and Prejudice: the sugary colours signal the export of Jane Austen’s “two inches of ivory” world to the arch land of Regency Romance.

to be continued

The audio version of A Worthy Wife by Barbara Metzger, read by Pippa Rathborne, is available now on Audible, Amazon and iTunes.

22 comments on “A Regency Romance



  2. PJR says:

    Hello, Mary,

    Yes, it will be my pleasure to tell you when the audiobook is available. (I have just finished the initial recordings but they still have to go through technical processing by my sound engineer and then Audible’s publishing procedures.) I will contact you here, and also announce publication on https://pipparathborneactress.wordpress.com/

    With best wishes from Pippa


  3. Mary says:

    Ms Rathborne,
    Since I have access to the artist, will you let me know when you have finished Ms Lockhart”s Letters? or when it is available?


  4. PJR says:

    What an interesting detail about the casting of Arsenic and Old Lace – a film I’ve always loved. I enjoy most Bob Hope films, too, but I agree that casting Grant was definitely the best outcome – a “straight actor” with a gift for light comedy maintains suspension of disbelief better than a personality comedian (however winsome) – not necessary to break the fourth wall in such a charming old play.

    Yes, I am working on Barbara Metzger’s delightful Miss Lockharte’s Letters now!


  5. Mary says:

    Ms Rathborne, I do so enjoy your performances. I am reminded of Cary Grant’s performance in Arsenic and Old Lace (circa 1944). Bob Hope was originally considered for that role. I could not imagine Bob Hope in that role. Cary Grant as Mortimer Brewster was Mortimer Brewster. He made it look effortless and I forgot that it was Cary Grant playing a role.
    For narration of audio books, the narrator must assume all the roles in the production and I imagine that that is more difficult than acting only one part. In the books that you have narrated, I cannot imagine another narrator in your place (like Hope instead of Grant. It would not have worked or have been as special).Thank you for your good works. Well done!
    And I spoke via email to the powers that be at Untreed Reads and was delighted to to be told that one of my favorite works by Ms Metzger is in production and will be available and that you are narrating!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. PJR says:

    FYI I have posted this as an appreciation of the relationship between actor and audience. https://pipparathborneactress.wordpress.com/2022/02/01/symbiosis/


  7. PJR says:

    My God, Mary, I have just read your generous review of The Legacy. Your praise humbles me. I am very grateful because it is hard to make headway in the overcrowded audiobook market. Most of all, I am relieved that you enjoyed the storytelling: that is the most precious thing.


  8. PJR says:

    Thank you, Mary. I do hope you enjoy listening.


  9. Mary says:

    No I will purchased, you should be paid for your labors 🙂
    And I will review. Thanks for the heads up.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. PJR says:

    Mary, you might be interested to know that Edith Layton’s “The Legacy and Other Stories” is now available at Audible https://pipparathborneactress.wordpress.com/2022/01/07/legacy-and-trust/.

    Let me know if you would like a complimentary copy (under no duress to review!) and I will send you a code via email.


  11. Mary says:

    I have to say YEEEESSS! I so loved the late Edith Layton’s books. OMG, if you are doing her books, it is an automatic purchase. You will imbibe her unique style with style. Something to look forward to in 2022. As an aside, I hope that they will let you rerecord A True Lady.

    So cool, two years ago, I contacted Untreed Reads asking about Metzger audio books. I got my answer. I then asked about Edith Layton and suggested you as a narrator and I was told that the family of Ms Layton was managing her works. Two years later…….

    Best wishes

    Liked by 1 person

  12. PJR says:

    Thank you, Mary, for your warm and generous comment. It means everything to me to know somebody has enjoyed listening. I am currently finishing work on a collection of stories by Edith Layton, and I hope to be commissioned to read another Metzger in the new year.

    Best wishes, Pippa


  13. Mary says:

    A million years later and I am just discovering PJR’s following. I am a super fan, having listened to almost all of Ms Rathborne’s audio Regencies. All for sure from Metzger and one from Harrison. I look forward to your future releases. You make characters come to life.. Well done.

    And yes the Regency period in literature was/is amazing, providing vicarious nostalgia and entertainment for descending generations (authors, narrators , readers, etc,) But in reality it was not a good place to be if you were not of the aristocracy, nobility and male…. oh and an adult.

    Liked by 1 person

  14. […] John Arthur Douglas Bloomfield, 2nd Baron Bloomfield, already a career diplomat at the age of seventeen, a pillar of the Establishment trying desperately to look like poet, libertarian political writer and social outcast Lord Byron, painted at full Romantic throttle by Thomas Lawrence, 1819. National Portrait Gallery. (Image: Wikipedia) Extract from THE ENDURING APPEAL OF REGENCY ROMANCE by Pippa Rathborne […]


  15. They may lead nowhere, but nowhere is a terribly difficult spot to get to. I think you are providing a delightful service. I’ve spent a good chunk of my life trying to get nowhere and I always, sometimes lamentably, end up somewhere.


  16. PJR says:

    Thank you, Thomas. I’ve missed a certain reader who sees through me. Your name evokes a 16th century philosopher or practitioner of the dark arts who has chosen to visit the over-developed 21st century. Thank you for following my blogs, but I’m afraid they lead nowhere.

    Liked by 1 person

  17. Hmm… Very interesting. I’ve missed this sort of historical analysis dearly! Glad to hear your audio book is doing well. I did happen to hear a “lost” demo of you doing a reading of some weird piece by an odd fellow by the name of Eric something or other.


  18. PJR says:

    Can’t we have sanctions against Jane Austen adaptations? The only one I’ve liked is “Clueless” – because it borrowed from, rather than traduced, “Emma” – though I admit the Saint Emma / Ang Lee “Sn’S” was emotionally truthful….Everything else is a tritification of Austen.

    Liked by 1 person

  19. Yes, you’re right, and I hadn’t thought about it before, that the Regency period does seem more modern than the periods following it. That time period really does seem like a rational one. I’m going to keep that in mind the next time I see a millionth re-make of Pride and Prejudice.

    Liked by 3 people

  20. […] Source: A Regency Romance […]

    Liked by 1 person

  21. Fascinating, Pippa, and what you say makes absolute sense.

    Liked by 1 person

  22. beetleypete says:

    Good luck to you both with the book, Pippa. I see that it has thirty-one five-star reviews already on Amazon, so that bodes well.
    Best wishes as always, Pete. x

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s